Hillsborough Value

5309 Pagnotta Pl, Lutz, FL 33558

3,940 sqft, built 2001. Just value for 2026: $643,880.

Hillsborough County account 1827205GW000003000250U

In line with similar homes

8 similar homes nearby support a value at or above your county value.

Just value$643,880
Similar homes$659,043
No gap: similar homes are at or above the county value · bars start at $0

How sure: High · 8 similar homes (5 shown below) · public records only

Just value
$643,880
Tax year 2026 · the Property Appraiser's market value as of January 1, before exemptions and assessment limits
Living area
3,940 sqft
$163 per sqft
Year built
2001
Homestead
Yes
Owner-occupied exemption on file

What we found

Similar homes' just values

Weak

2 of 8 similar homes are assessed lower per square foot. Their similarity-weighted median is $167.27/sqft, which supports a value of $659,043.

Compare this assessment

Start with the county value and property facts, then review appraisal comps, recent sales, and prior-year changes to decide whether the assessment is worth challenging. The comps on this page are free to review; email sign-in is only used to save a printable report.

For nearby context, browse ZIP 33558 assessment pages.

Appeal deadline

The 2026 appeal deadline was . 2027 notices usually arrive in August.

Deadline rule: Within 25 days after the TRIM notice is mailed. The exact date is printed on your TRIM notice. Evidence is reviewed by the Value Adjustment Board (VAB). Dates checked against the official source.

Assessment snapshot

These public HCPA records highlight what may be worth checking before you file.

  • Assessment changeThe just value decreased 2.0% from $657,107 in 2025 to $643,880 in 2026.
  • Just value per square footThe current public record shows about $163 per square foot before any comparable-property adjustments.
  • Nearby comparison areaThis page starts the equity review with public records for ZIP 33558.
  • Neighborhood value signalAmong 500 residential records in the same neighborhood, the average just value is about $201 per square foot.
  • Area year-over-year signalNearby residential records with prior-year values stayed about flat on average.

Comparable assessments

Showing 5 of the 8 similar homes in this property's equity comparison, from public appraisal records.

  • 17624 Archland Pass Rd, Lutz, FL 33558
    3,896 sqft | $166/sqft | built 2002 | Similar size (3,896 vs 3,940 sqft); Similar age (2002 vs 2001); Similar lot size (12,031 vs 12,214 sqft)
    $645,773
  • 5527 Winhawk Way, Lutz, FL 33558
    3,861 sqft | $189/sqft | built 2001 | Similar size (3,861 vs 3,940 sqft); Built same year (2001); Similar lot size (12,348 vs 12,214 sqft)
    $729,275
  • 5451 Winhawk Way, Lutz, FL 33558
    3,973 sqft | $161/sqft | built 2000 | Similar size (3,973 vs 3,940 sqft); Similar age (2000 vs 2001); Similar lot size (12,515 vs 12,214 sqft)
    $639,420
  • 16906 Melissa Ann Dr, Lutz, FL 33558
    3,860 sqft | $145/sqft | built 2001 | Similar size (3,860 vs 3,940 sqft); Built same year (2001); Similar lot size (11,614 vs 12,214 sqft)
    $558,575
  • 5305 Pagnotta Pl, Lutz, FL 33558
    3,782 sqft | $173/sqft | built 2000 | Similar size (3,782 vs 3,940 sqft); Similar age (2000 vs 2001); Similar lot size (12,357 vs 12,214 sqft)
    $653,984

Recent comparable sales

No usable comparable sales are available in this data snapshot.

Public appraisal comparison for 2026. Prepared . Appraisal source: Hillsborough County Property Appraiser. Sales data checked in this snapshot: . Matches consider available size, age, location and property characteristics. How comparisons work.

Value history

Down 2.0% in 2026 from 2025.

Just value by tax year, with the change from the previous year listed
Tax yearJust valueChangeChange %
2026$643,880−$13,227−2.0%
2025$657,107——
1-year total−$13,227−2.0%